Whatever
happened to "play to the whistle"? By taking matters into their own
hands and stopping play, players are only putting themselves in the
dock, on the block, and up the proverbial garden path.
When a player
apparently suffers an injury during play, referees are the only ones who
have the authority to decide whether or not to stop a match. Players
ignore this at their peril.
Tuesday's (20 November 2012) controversial goal by
Shakhtar Donetsk against Nordsjaelland in the Champions League is a prime example. When a
Nordsjaelland player went down injured, players voluntarily stopped play
in the middle of the park. After the player had been taken off the
pitch to receive treatment, the referee restarted play with a drop ball.
It was uncontested and Shakhtar Donetsk midfielder Willian gently
booted the ball back to his opponents' half. However, Willian's
teammate, Brazilian Luiz Adriano, apparently did not realise a sporting
gesture was being played out, and so ran on to the "pass" to the
amazement of the static Nordsjaelland defenders, rounded the dismayed
goalkeeper, and promptly scored.
Uefa has now charged Adriano with unsporting behaviour and he has been
suspended for their next Champions League match (for
"violation of the principles of conduct").
There are many levels of inquiry here, and one easy solution.
First,
in return for what most people perceive to be an unsporting goal, why
did the Shakhtar Donetsk defenders refuse to allow their opponents a
walk-in goal immediately after that misunderstanding?
"Half their team seemed to think [it would be fair], but the other
half didn't," Nordsjaelland captain Nicolai Stokholm said. At that
moment, Shakhtar Donetsk had no leader to tell the whole team what they
should do. This would explain the team's mixed stance.
It also explains how seriously some players take their profession,
with many having differing interpretations of how sporting behaviour
fits into the game, if at all.
Second, why was Adriano seemingly unrepentant about his actions? "It
was instinct, I see the ball and I dribbled and I scored a goal," he
said. Adriano is basically saying a professional soccer player is
supposed to win matches. Does this mindset override sporting gestures
such as stopping play for an injured opponent?
Third, why did players stop play in first place? How did they know
the player was injured and not faking injury? Are players trained in
medical triage? With all these risks, why would professional players
compromise themselves by taking up the referee's responsibility? It's
not simply a matter of being sporting, since stopping play can also be
trying to gain "brownie points" in the public eye.
And, why did the players not kick the ball out of play? They just
stopped and looked around aimlessly, which reveals they really did not
know what to do and were probably seeking guidance. Therefore, they
should always "play to the whistle".
Players stopping play first came to prominence at the 1986 World Cup
in Mexico, when Belgium played Spain in the quarter-finals. Even in the
baking summer heat, and having to play extra time, whenever a player
from any team went down his opponents would refuse to take advantage,
and instead opted to kick the ball out of play. This was genuine and
sincere "fair play".
But things have moved on since then, most notably professionalism and
monetary rewards have brought increased cynicism and gamesmanship to
the modern game.
This is why it is important to let one person, the match referee,
decide whether or not to call a halt when a player is apparently
injured. Referees will stop play only if, in their opinion, a player is
seriously injured. A serious injury is something of the magnitude of a
broken limb. However, judging by many players' reactions, it would seem a
little knock or slap is plenty enough to stop a match.
At the amateur and parks level, stopping the game works beautifully
for almost any injury, either real or apparent. But at the competitive
and professional level, it is best left to the man in the middle to
decide whether or not to stop play. This prevents players from duping
opponents.
Remember the 2010 World Cup final between the Netherlands and Spain?
No love was lost in this ultimately competitive match. With Spain
eventually taking a 1-0 lead during extra-time, the Netherlands were
frantically trying to find the equalizer. In the 120th minute, Spain's
Fernando Torres pulled up apparently with a hamstring injury. The
sporting thing to do would have been to kick the ball out of play.
History shows the Netherlands did not give a fig about sportsmanship, as
they continued to attack Spain's goal.
This week's lesson: At the professional level, sportsmanship is for suckers.